Skip to main content

5 Takeaways: DET 0-TOR 3

 

Matthews celebrates 60 (Mark Blinch, Getty Images)

    Auston Matthews became the first player since Steven Stamkos to score 60 goals in a single regular season with a two-goal performance last night.
    Here are my 5 takeaways as the Maple Leafs seal home-ice advantage for the playoffs. 

1. Awesome Matthews

    He did it.
    What seemed like an inevitability a few weeks ago was suddenly looking unlikely, as Matthews suffered his longest goal-scoring drought of the season at the wrong time. But, like all elite players, Matthews got it done.
    By it, I obviously mean 60 goals in a season. It's a remarkable achievement that hasn't been achieved in a decade. It helps that scoring is way up this season (I mean, Chris Kreider has 52 goals for goodness' sake), but still nobody else had managed it. With 60 goals and 106 points, Matthews has put up the best season by a Leafs player in my lifetime. It's becoming obvious that the American superstar is going to win the Hart Memorial Trophy at the NHL Awards gala this offseason. 
    Matthews lives in his own world in terms of goal-scoring. But as the Athletic's Jonas Siegel broke down in a recent article, his brilliant defensive impacts separate him from the rest. Data analyst Dom Luszczyszyn has created a formula that measures defensive impacts. It isn't perfect by any means, but it combines statistics including xG against and high-danger opportunities against. Let's look at the top 10 scorers in the league this season and their 82-game pace for defensive rating, per Luszcyszyn. 

Auston Matthews   16.3
Johnny Gaudreau   15.8
Matthew Tkachuk   11.6
Mitch Marner   10.5
Connor McDavid   10.5
Kirill Kaprizov   7.5
Steven Stamkos   0.9
JT Miller   -3.1
Leon Draisaitl   -5.8
Jonathan Huberdeau   -13.7

    Now that isn't perfect by any means (Connor McDavid is nowhere near as good a defender as Mitch Marner, even if he has taken steps this season). However, what it shows is that not only is Matthews a goal-scoring beast, he's also one of the best defensive players in the NHL. For the skeptics that say "Oh, he doesn't play short-handed," there is only one player on this list that does play on the penalty kill (it's Mitch Marner, by the way; man, I love this duo). 
    Though I'm the Takeaway King, I may have to cede my title to Matthews. His 92 takeaways are 20 more than the next forward. He's a defensive beast and obviously a generational scorer.

2. Home Sweet Home

    The optimist in me says "The Leafs are getting home-ice advantage. They've been great at home and this could push them over the top!" The cynic in me says "Oh, the Leafs get to blow game 7 in front of their own fans this year." Guess who's probably right? Yep, you guessed it, the cynic.
    Either way, if I push away my relentless pessimism for one moment, I can admit that this is a big W for Toronto. Their tough trip into Florida left the team in danger of missing out on home-ice advantage to Tampa Bay, but they've sealed it after Game 81. 
    Toronto's 30-8-2 record at Scotiabank Arena is the third best home record in the league. Their away record (23-13-5) is a much less satisfying tenth place in the NHL. 
    Crucially, Jack Campbell's splits have been much better at home than they have on the road. At home, "Soupy" is 19-6 with a 2.22 goals against average and a .924 save percentage. On the road, he is 12-9 with a 3.14 GAA and .904 SV%. Pretty big difference and it could be the difference between a series win and a series loss. That extra game could be critical.

3. Campbell Offers a Glimpse

    Among all goalies with at least 5 starts in April, Campbell's .915 SV% is top-10 in the league. I've constantly been saying that a healthy Campbell is Toronto's most important asset. That includes Matthews and Marner.
    The differential between Campbell at his best and Campbell at his worst is bewildering. It probably isn't a good thing that he drops off so much in his off games, but if Toronto can somehow string together 2 months of good Jack Campbell, they have as good a chance at winning the Cup as anybody. If we get bad Jack Campbell, Tampa could take the series home in 5. 
    "Soupy" was once again good against Detroit. (admittedly, not much of a test) He looked composed and his puck-tracking ability looked quite good. If he can shake off his midseason slumber, the Leafs have an elite goalie manning the crease. 
    He made my top 50 NHL players for a reason. 

4. Robertson Continues to Underwhelm in NHL

    Look, Nick Robertson is good at hockey. In the 2019-20 OHL season, Robertson scored 55 goals in 46 games for the Peterborough Petes. A bad player couldn't do that. Since returning from a major injury, he has 15 goals and 12 assists for 27 points in 26 games against professionals in the AHL. A bad player couldn't do that. But for whatever reason, every time he comes up to the NHL, I just feel disappointed. 
    He's 20 years old and he's had brutal injury luck. Only managing 2 points in 16 NHL games might be excusable for that reason. But he simply doesn't look polished at all, which is a bad thing considering he is a beacon of hope in Toronto's middling prospect pipeline.
    He looks rusty, a step below par. Robertson always seems to bring energy to NHL games, but he is allowed clear looks and is getting an amazing opportunity alongside John Tavares and Ilya Mikheyev, yet he can't take advantage. 
    Of course I'm not giving up on Nick Robertson. But I wish that he could have a legitimate argument to join Toronto's roster for the postseason. He simply hasn't played well enough in his limited opportunities to do so, which means we're stuck with Kyle Clifford playing multiple games against Tampa's skilled bottom-six.

5. Crucial Offseason for Stevie Y

    Similarly to the Ottawa Senators, Detroit seems to have lost the plot when it comes to ending a rebuild. Rebuilds can't go on for a decade or more, and when the Red Wings hired Steve Yzerman, the architect of the 2020 Tampa Bay Lightning team, he was supposed to get the rebuild over with. Yet here we are and Detroit is facing yet another season outside of the playoffs.
    Yzerman is facing a job-defining season in the front office this year. He'll have a top-10 pick to add to Detroit's already stacked prospect system. He has an obscene amount of cap space to throw around and make his team more competitive. In Dylan Larkin, Jakub Vrana and Moritz Seider, Stevie Y already has the star power to construct a playoff roster. My biggest question with Detroit is whether they have the right coach.
    Jeff Blashill is one of the longest tenured coaches in the NHL, but he simply hasn't done anything of note with this franchise. He could still stay behind the bench, but it seems obvious that Yzerman is at least on the lookout for a new head coach. If he can identify the prime candidate, Detroit can get set to make some noise.
    If they stick with Blashill or choose the wrong option, another season of mediocrity awaits.


ALL STATS COURTESY OF MONEYPUCK AND THE ATHLETIC
NO COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT INTENDED

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Top 100 NHL Players for 2025-26

Leon Draisaitl (Steph Chambers/Getty Images)       It's been a significant amount of time since I last deigned to engage in the primitive art of player rankings. In 2023, I wrote an article with the purpose of outlining the top 50 players in the National Hockey League. Now that the busy camp summer has wrapped up and the school semester is yet to kick into high gear, I figured it would be a worthy exercise to revisit my old article and provide some much-needed updates to the list.      While I acknowledge the vast number of fun narratives that could be derived from a Sincere Sports player ranking, I don't mince my words when I call this a "primitive art." In actuality, separating the most talented hockey players on the planet by mere numbers is frankly incapable of doing justice to their extreme ability. Truthfully, a tier-based system would be more accurate for encapsulating the various nuances of splitting hairs between a dynamic right winger and a steady...

Predicting 2030 Olympics Rosters for Team Canada and Team USA

  Connor McDavid couldn't lead Canada to the gold (Hockey Canada)     Well, you could say I moved on quickly.     In actuality, I still feel incredibly torn up about the result of Sunday's instant classic Olympic gold medal final between Canada and the United States of America. It feels cruel that we must wait another four years before an Olympic rematch between these two hockey powerhouses, as I desperately want another bite at the cherry before I accept the fact that Canada is no longer the king of the hockey world for the first time in over 16 years. However, my disappointment is masked by my excitement regarding the supreme quality of hockey with which we were treated and the potential for even more best-on-best competition in the coming years.     If you were expecting an overreaction from me about the game, you won't find it here. It sucks to lose, obviously, and losing to the Americans makes the result far worse. You don't have to be highly inte...

Projecting the Canadian and American 2026 Olympic Rosters

  Connor McDavid's unforgettable winner (Getty Images)     When you're hot, you're hot.      Sincere Sports hasn't been on a roll like this since I started forfeiting technology during the summers and turned my writing abilities to abstract assessments of Hannah Arendt's banality of evil, instead of superficial sports recaps. I can't quite understand the reasons for this newfound writing binge. It certainly isn't the pathetically bad Maple Leafs team that are currently getting caved in by the retooling Boston Bruins as I put the finishing touches on this article. Maybe Montreal's sudden influx of winter weather has put me in a mood for hockey? Perhaps the Toronto Blue Jays' devastating Game 7 World Series loss has caused me to disassociate with MLB free agency? Regardless of the reasons, I hope some people can appreciate this burst of content before I inevitably go on another hiatus until the World Juniors.      Collectively, the hockey world...