Skip to main content

5 Takeaways: DAL 0-TOR 4

 

Erik Kallgren shuts down Joel Kiviranta (Kevin Sousa, Getty Images)

    No Auston Matthews, no problem. 25-year old rookie goaltender Erik Kallgren shut down the high-flying Dallas Stars, as the Leafs put in their best performance in weeks.
    Here are my 5 takeaways from an unforgettable night for the Swedish netminder.

1. Breaking Out of his Kall

    Erik Kallgren (pronounced Shall-grin) was the Leafs' best player on his first ever NHL start. Signed as a free agent from the Swedish Elite League's Vaxjo Lakers, Kallgren was expected to be a depth goalie for the Marlies with potential to improve. However, with Petr Mrazek performing at a nightmarish level and Jack Campbell sidelined with a rib injury, coach Sheldon Keefe had no choice but to start Kallgren.
    He performed admirably, showing poise and composure far beyond his years. He tracked pucks very well, particularly with screened shots which both Leafs goalies have struggled with in recent weeks. His positioning was excellent, a welcome change from the erratic Mrazek. Despite probably being very nervous, on his first start in The Show, Kallgren had a couple beautiful stops that neither Mrazek nor Campbell has been saving lately.
    As a result of his play, the entire team looked revitalized. Since the beginning of 2022, it hasn't looked like the Leafs' skaters have much confidence in their goalies. There seems to be a distinct lack of trust and the message has been displayed by the grim looks of Toronto's star players after a stupid goal. However, in this game, the Leafs' players felt confident advancing the puck and settling down on the penalty kill, as they knew that their last line of defense was strong and capable. This led to not only the best game from a Leafs' goaltender in a while, but the Leafs' best overall performance since beating the Carolina Hurricanes right after the All-Star break. 
    I don't think this is a signal that Kallgren is set to take the starter's job, though. I predict that he and Mrazek will split the duties about 50-50 until Campbell returns, in which case "Soupy" should get the majority of starts. But if Kallgren keeps this up consistently (let's not forget he was very good in the Coyotes game, too), crazier things have happened. We've seen unassuming goalies like Matt Murray and Jordan Binnington steal the starter jobs late in the season before leading their respective teams to a Stanley Cup. Why can't Kallgren join that group?

2. The Russian Bear Proves Me Right 

    After the overtime win over the Columbus Blue Jackets, I stated in my takeaways that it was time to consider pairing Ilya Lyubushkin with Morgan Rielly. My reasoning was that Lyubushkin was developing a reputation as a good safety blanket with underrated puck skills. These players have traditionally been able to get the best out of Morgan Rielly, as their physicality and ability to defend against the rush allows Rielly to skate forward and chip in offensively. Though Rielly has improved defensively, his offense is what makes him a star defenseman. 
    For the first time since Lyubushkin was acquired, Keefe paired the two rearguards for an entire game and I was very pleased with the results. The Russian logged 17:47, notching 6 hits and playing his trademark gritty style. The advanced analytics weren't stunning, but often physical players like Lyubushkin perform much better on the eye test than they do with the numbers. 
    I personally really liked how the two players meshed and the Leafs' defense is becoming very interesting. I have legitimately no clue what the D corps will look like for Game 1 of the playoffs.

3. Dissecting the Leafs' Defense

    This Rielly-Lyubushkin situation is more important than you might think. It could completely change how GM Kyle Dubas approaches the trade deadline. They still have Jake Muzzin recovering and players like Travis Dermott and Timothy Liljegren still aren't consistent members of the team.
    With Jake Muzzin, in particular, if all Leaf defensemen are healthy, he may not even be good enough to crack the team. As outrageous as that sounds, we have to consider how poor Muzzin has played this season. The Leafs are obviously looking for a right-handed defenseman for the second or third pair. We'll have to see if this Lyubushkin-Rielly combo works out over a prolonged period of time, but if he does, I don't think that Muzzin cracks the top-4. The Leafs' defense could look like this.

Rielly-Lyubushkin
Brodie-Holl
Sandin-?

    Brodie-Holl and Rielly-Lyubushkin have good when on the ice together. Rasmus Sandin's play absolutely warrants a starting role for the postseason roster. So, who plays next to him? I think these are the options, in terms of likeliness.

1. Trade for a very cheap right-handed defenseman (Justin Braun, Mark Pysyk, Luke Schenn), but still play Muzzin beside Sandin

Rielly-Lyubushkin
Brodie-Holl
Muzzin-Sandin
Dermott-Braun/Pysyk/Schenn

2. Trade for a cheap left-handed defenseman (Jacob Middleton, Michael del Zotto, Robert Hagg) and shuffle up the top-4

Rielly-Brodie
Muzzin-Holl
Sandin-Lyubushkin
Middleton/del Zotto/Hagg-Liljegren/Dermott

3. Trade for a top-4 defenseman (Hampus Lindholm, Mark Giordano, Ben Chiarot) by keeping Jake Muzzin on LTIR and bringing him back for the playoffs

Rielly-Brodie
Lindholm/Giordano/Muzzin-Chiarot
Sandin-Lyubushkin/Holl
Rubins-Holl/Lyubushkin

4. Don't make any trades and shuffle up the top-4

Rielly-Brodie
Muzzin-Holl
Sandin-Lyubushkin
Dermott-Liljegren

`I think that covers most likely options for the Leafs' management staff. Let's see what path they choose.

4. Could Keefe Break up the Best Line in Hockey?

    That's right: more lineup speculation. 
    With Auston Matthews out after a harsh suspension, Keefe shuffled his forwards around, notably making a line with Michael Bunting, John Tavares and Mitch Marner.
    This trio excelled, earning a ridiculous 89.2 xGF% and an elite 77.2 Corsi%. Tavares picked up two points in the first 12 minutes of play alongside Marner and the results were good enough to induce some speculation about whether this line could last, even after Matthews returns from his suspension.
    Bunting-Matthews-Marner has undoubtedly been the best line in hockey this season and he would be understandably hesitant to break them up. However, Stanley Cup champions require bold moves to get the best out of their roster. Frankly, I'd rather have two A- lines than one A+ line. 
    For a forward group as talented as Toronto's, it's unacceptable that their offense is completely driven by one line. It would be worth trying to keep Bunting-Tavares-Marner together, in my opinion. 
    I could see Keefe opting for either one of these lineups.

Kerfoot-Matthews-Nylander
Bunting-Tavares-Marner
Engvall-Kampf-Mikheyev
Robertson-Spezza-Kase

OR 

Kase-Matthews-Nylander
Bunting-Tavares-Marner
Engvall-Kampf-Mikheyev
Spezza-Kerfoot-Simmonds

OR 

Bunting-Matthews-Nylander
Robertson-Tavares-Marner
Engvall-Kampf-Mikheyev
Kerfoot-Spezza-Kase

5. Jake Oettinger Impresses Once Again

    One of the league's most underrated goalies, per my estimation, is Jake Oettinger of the Dallas Stars. He once again proved my theory with a stunning performance on Tuesday night. Though he lost the goaltending duel to Erik Kallgren, Oettinger was Dallas' best player, saving 2.7 goals above expected. He made a jaw-dropping glove save on William Nylander that I literally celebrated before realizing it wasn't in the net.
    For good reason, Jason Robertson, Roope Hintz, Joe Pavelski and Miro Heiskanen get most of the credit around Dallas' season. However, I personally think that "Otter" deserves a mention in that conversation. At just 23 years old, the former first-round pick will only improve. If Dallas can fix their depth issues and become a legitimate Stanley Cup contender, I expect that Oettinger will be in the conversation for a Vezina Trophy one day.  


ALL STATS COURTESY OF MONEYPUCK AND NATURAL STAT TRICK
NO COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT INTENDED

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Top 100 NHL Players for 2025-26

Leon Draisaitl (Steph Chambers/Getty Images)       It's been a significant amount of time since I last deigned to engage in the primitive art of player rankings. In 2023, I wrote an article with the purpose of outlining the top 50 players in the National Hockey League. Now that the busy camp summer has wrapped up and the school semester is yet to kick into high gear, I figured it would be a worthy exercise to revisit my old article and provide some much-needed updates to the list.      While I acknowledge the vast number of fun narratives that could be derived from a Sincere Sports player ranking, I don't mince my words when I call this a "primitive art." In actuality, separating the most talented hockey players on the planet by mere numbers is frankly incapable of doing justice to their extreme ability. Truthfully, a tier-based system would be more accurate for encapsulating the various nuances of splitting hairs between a dynamic right winger and a steady...

Predicting 2030 Olympics Rosters for Team Canada and Team USA

  Connor McDavid couldn't lead Canada to the gold (Hockey Canada)     Well, you could say I moved on quickly.     In actuality, I still feel incredibly torn up about the result of Sunday's instant classic Olympic gold medal final between Canada and the United States of America. It feels cruel that we must wait another four years before an Olympic rematch between these two hockey powerhouses, as I desperately want another bite at the cherry before I accept the fact that Canada is no longer the king of the hockey world for the first time in over 16 years. However, my disappointment is masked by my excitement regarding the supreme quality of hockey with which we were treated and the potential for even more best-on-best competition in the coming years.     If you were expecting an overreaction from me about the game, you won't find it here. It sucks to lose, obviously, and losing to the Americans makes the result far worse. You don't have to be highly inte...

Projecting the Canadian and American 2026 Olympic Rosters

  Connor McDavid's unforgettable winner (Getty Images)     When you're hot, you're hot.      Sincere Sports hasn't been on a roll like this since I started forfeiting technology during the summers and turned my writing abilities to abstract assessments of Hannah Arendt's banality of evil, instead of superficial sports recaps. I can't quite understand the reasons for this newfound writing binge. It certainly isn't the pathetically bad Maple Leafs team that are currently getting caved in by the retooling Boston Bruins as I put the finishing touches on this article. Maybe Montreal's sudden influx of winter weather has put me in a mood for hockey? Perhaps the Toronto Blue Jays' devastating Game 7 World Series loss has caused me to disassociate with MLB free agency? Regardless of the reasons, I hope some people can appreciate this burst of content before I inevitably go on another hiatus until the World Juniors.      Collectively, the hockey world...